About

A fixture for New York deli sandwiches in downtown Smithfield since 2003.

Locally Owned

Owned and operated by native New Yorker Scott Gandolph and his wife Lisa. Gotham’s opened its doors in July of 2003.

Scott was born and raised on Long Island, New York.

Scott and Lisa have been working in the food industry for over 35 years.

A Family Venture

Scott and Lisa have 6 children (all of whom have worked or do work in the deli) and 9 Grandchildren.

At Gotham’s, we continue to enjoy serving the people of Johnston County by bringing a taste of New York to the South.

Lisa is a master at making “Fresh-Made” salads and desserts, a talent she has passed onto our kids.

Gotham’s features many meats and cheeses to go along with our specialty baked breads

Those meats include: Roast Beef, Turkey, Ham, Pastrami, Pepperoni, Corn Beef, and Breaded Chicken. If your in the mood for a “Real NY Sandwich”, Hail a Cab, or just stop by downtown Smithfield, NC, You will think your visiting New York City.